Mar - 16 - 2012

Some People Believe That College Students Should Consider Only Their Own Talents - With A Free Essay Revie



Some people believe that college students should consider only their own talents and interests when choosing a field of study. Others believe that college students should base their choice of a field of study on the availability of jobs in that field.

Write a response in which you discuss which view more closely aligns with your own position and explain your reasoning for the position you take. In developing and supporting your position, you should address both of the views presented.

I agree with the statement that students should take up their field of study based on their talents and interests and not based on the availability of jobs in that field. Students are being educated enough in their schools for them to explore and find out what they are interested in and take up that field of study in college. The main purpose of education is to give a deep knowledge for students on what they want to learn and explore rather than diverting them to the path where they can earn money.

First of all, when students take up courses based on their field of study, they show eagerness in every phase of learning new things, question theories that have already been stated and get a deep knowledge of what they study. But when students take up a course just because there are more job opportunities for students who take up that course, then they would just learn the syllabus by heart, get high scores and get a job rather than understand the syllabus and gain deep knowledge, which is the main purpose of education.

Secondly, when a student takes up a course just for the sake of getting a job then after finishing the course and getting a job, there is no guarantee that the student would like the job. Once such students start exploring their interests as they work and if they figure out that the work they are doing is not what they are interested in, they would not succeed in their work also. On the other hand, when students take up courses based on their field of interest, they gain deep knowledge of what they are being taught and enjoy learning. This would make them satisfied with their work when they get a job after graduating and hence succeed in their career life.

Additionally, if students choose to study courses that they are interested in, then there is a good chance that they would dive deep into those fields and do research. They might even come up with new inventions in those fields, hence adding value to their nation and to their field of interest.

To summarize, students should be encouraged to choose their college courses based on their interests rather than on the job opportunities after graduation. Only when students take up courses of their interest will they be successful in their studies and career.

______________________________________________

ESSAY REVIEW

Your first argument is that “when students take up courses based on their [talents and interests], they show eagerness..., question theories..., and get a deep knowledge.” You don’t explain why you believe that, and the idea that such students would “question theories” seems too specific here. The idea that they might be eager is reasonable enough, I suppose, and perhaps doesn’t need to be explained, but what does need to be explained is why these facts, if they are facts, would justify a student choosing a field of study that leads to no jobs.

The second part of your second paragraph has a similar problem. The claim that students pursuing fields of study based on the consideration of future job opportunities would “just learn the syllabus by heart” is not justified, is much too specific, and again doesn’t really lead to an explanation of why you think students shouldn’t do that.

So, if you want to argue that students should pursue their interests, then you need to explain why their first concern should not be future job security. You need to argue explicitly, in other words, that job satisfaction (which you go on to address in your next paragraph) is more important than job security. And of course you cannot simply claim that those who pursue their interests will be “satisfied with their work when they get a job,” since their getting a job at all is necessarily in doubt when they choose personal interests over job security.

Best, EJ.


Related posts

  • RSS
  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
  • advertisement